- The Undisputed Era win Tag Team of the Year
- Adam Cole wins Male Competitor of the Year
- Shayna Baszler wins Female Competitor of the Year
- Gargano vs. Cole wins Rivalry of the Year
- Dakota Kai wins Future Star of the Year
- TakeOver: WarGames wins TakeOver of the Year
- Keith Lee wins Breakout Star of the Year
- Gargano vs. Cole is NXT’s Match of the Year
- Adam Cole wins Overall Competitor of the Year
- Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic entrants revealed
- Triple H poses with the NXT Year-End Award winners