Who won the 2019 Superstar Shake-up?

Other than the fans, of course.

But seriously, whether or not you dug WWE’s narratively confusing 2019 roster re-alignment or not, it’s still fun to check out the show’s line-ups and pick which one you think made out better. History shows that first impressions aren’t always right (remember when everyone was sure SmackDown would suck after the 2016 draft?), and this year’s even trickier than most - there are still a few Superstars who haven’t been assigned to team red or team blue.

Let’s just take a look at each show’s line-up as currently listed on WWE.com and see what we think, though... shall we?

WWE.com

AJ Styles
Akam
Aleister Black
Alexa Bliss
Alicia Fox
Andrade
Baron Corbin
Bo Dallas
Bobby Lashley
Bobby Roode
Braun Strowman
Bray Wyatt
Brock Lesnar
Cedric Alexander
Curt Hawkins
Curtis Axel
Dana Brooke
Dash Wilder
Dolph Ziggler
Drew McIntyre
EC3
Eric Young
Erik
Fandango
Gran Metalik
Heath Slater
Ivar
Jey Uso
Jimmy Uso
Jinder Mahal
Kalisto
Konnor
Lacey Evans
Lince Dorado
Lio Rush
Mojo Rawley
Naomi
Natalya
Nia Jax
No Way Jose
Rey Mysterio
Rezar
Rhyno
Ricochet
Ronda Rousey
Ruby Riott
Sami Zayn
Samir Singh
Sarah Logan
Sasha Banks
Scott Dawson
Seth Rollins
Sunil Singh
Tamina
The Miz
Titus O’Neil
Tyler Breeze
Viktor
Zack Ryder
Zelina Vega

WWE.com

Aiden English
Alexander Wolfe
Ali
Apollo Crews
Asuka
Bayley
Becky Lynch
Big E
Big Show
Billie Kay
Buddy Murphy
Carmella
Cesaro
Chad Gable
Charlotte Flair
Daniel Bryan
Elias
Ember Moon
Epico Colon
Finn Bálor
Harper
Jeff Hardy
Kairi Sane
Kane
Karl Anderson
Kevin Owens
Killian Dain
Kofi Kingston
Lana
Lars Sullivan
Liv Morgan
Luke Gallows
Mandy Rose
Matt Hardy
Mickie James
Otis
Peyton Royce
Primo Colon
R-Truth
Randy Orton
Roman Reigns
Rowan
Rusev
Samoa Joe*
Sheamus
Shelton Benjamin
Shinsuke Nakamura
Sin Cara
Sonya Deville
Tucker
Xavier Woods

Obviously, there are some question marks here. People who are nearly retired are listed, along with others out with injuries. Wrestlers who’ve allegedly informed the company they’re gone or leaving as soon as possible show up. The ruling McMahons are on both list at WWE.com, mixed in with announcers and non-wrestling managers.

Still, it’s enough to overreact to right now. And that’s what fans on the internet do best.

So click your pick below, and explain why you think it’s right in the comments below that!