'This is not my beautiful house!': A stagnant CM Punk shouldn't cast stones
The closing segment of Raw was one wrestling fans had seen many times before: the contract signing.
The champion and the challenger are brought into the ring with usually nothing more than a table, the contract itself and an authority figure to make sure all the T's are crossed and the I's dotted.
It usually goes one of two ways. The first way being that both wrestlers sign the contract and then start brawling. The second option is one signs, then they brawl, and finally the other puts pen to paper while the other is either running to the hills or knocked out on the mat.
That's the formula and without fail, you'll see that nine times out of 10.
That 10th time would be the contract signing involving CM Punk, of course. And he was right to point that out last night. He got on the stick and questioned why they didn't just sign the paper and get to fighting since that's what it would inevitably lead to anyway.
He was saying what everyone already knew. The problem is he's already said it before. And when your character is one that is supposed to rail against all that is boring and stagnant, this comes off extremely hypocritical and annoying.
Punk promised to make the WWE fun again. But is it?
After Punk "returned" following his Money in the Bank title win, he spent most of his time involved in a feud with Triple H. The "Straight Edge Superstar" was convinced that the events keeping him away from the title were the machinations of Mr. Stephanie McMahon.
Leading up to their big match of Night of Champions, the two had a contract signing segment - something usually reserved for title bouts but hey, when you're the boss' son-in-law ... -- where Punk spouted out the same rant he did last night.
Standing inside the ring with his challengers - Alberto Del Rio and The Miz - I immediately felt like I had seen and heard this before. It was because I had.
CM Punk's character - once fresh and exciting - has been reduced to making fun of John Laurinaitis who - let's face it - isn't very hard to make fun of at all. Punk has been extoling change and that he wants to make the WWE fun again but his method of enacting such progress is simply to make fun of the stodgiest Raw General Manager since Mike Adamle.
The champ keeps going on about how boring "Funk Man" is but it's a case of the pot calling the kettle black since Punk himself is regurgitating material from just two months ago.
Cageside Czar Geno made a similar point to this in his post-Raw reactions where he said the champ is the "friend you have who you never watch movies with because he's always the first one to point out how ‘that would never happen'."
I couldn't agree more.
Wrestling fans are a curious bunch. I think they fall into one of three categories.
- A) The kiddos. These are the young ones who still think Randy Orton is some kind of man/snake hybrid and John Cena might just be the strongest man this side of Zeus himself.
- B) The smarks. They are hip to the business and think - scratch that, KNOW - they could run and book a promotion better than ... well, whoever is running or booking any promotion in question. They want things their way and if it's not, it sucks.
- C) The old wrestling fan. They've pretty much seen anything and everything under the squared circle sun and simply want to be entertained. It doesn't matter who wins or who loses, as long as it's entertaining, they're all for.
I would consider myself part of the third category. I used to be in the second, don't get me wrong. I thought I was pretty hot shit because I was hip to guys like Mitsuharu Misawa and preferred my Boyz to be Dudley rather than Hardy.
But I realized that I wasn't enjoying wrestling - even when it was legitimately good - because it wasn't what I wanted it to be inside my head. So I "Future Endeavored" the smark inside me and embraced my inner wrestling fan.
I don't need to be told that contract signings are boring and lame; I already know that. And if Punk feels the same, he should look to change it. It seems he's speaking to the portion of the audience who wants to sit at home, cross their arms, and say "Worst Raw ever."
If Punk really wants to change the WWE and make it fun again, then just make it fun. Stop being snarky and hip or edgy. There's nothing fun about not enjoying something.*
And above all else, don't fall into the same trappings that you claim have felled others.
It's not a good look, Punk.
* - The last couple of years of WCW notwithstanding. That stuff was enjoyable simply because of how huge of a clusterscrew it was.
33 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Judy Bagwell on a Pole Match
make it happen Punk
You knew someone was going to say this...
The WWE: Same as it ever was. Same as it ever was.
Time to spread a little chaos...
I'm forgiving of Punk, simply because I actually want to see him have matches with people.
I never looked forward to seeing Cena have a match with anybody, with the exception of his Punk matches this year, and with Punk, I actually want to see him face a few guys.
The real problem with WWE is that the booking’s just so horrible that they make it impossible for all but a few guys to get over. A match between workers the caliber of Punk and Del Rio should be something everyone wants to see regardless of how horrible the Miz is, but Del Rio’s heat has been so thoroughly killed in the past year that I honestly couldn’t give a shit about seeing him in a match with anybody, and I actually like Del Rio.
I'm still on the Punk bandwagon
But yeah he needs to move more towards the SCSA/Orton tweener
by Jonathan Loesche on Dec 6, 2011 4:02 PM EST reply actions
You know
When I think about a wrestler who was willing to say and do some different things, and just had a general air of coolness around him, but ultimately only really cared about himself and his own wallet, I could be talking about CM Punk, but I could also be talking about Kevin Nash.
Funny how that works out.
Writer (and a handsome one at that),
And the Valley Shook
I was thinking recently about how much Punk and Triple H have in common but Kevin Nash fits just as well.
by Mr. Sunny Days on Dec 6, 2011 4:13 PM EST up reply actions
What Punk either doesn't realize or does and just doens't give a fuck about
is that he IS Triple H.
Forget it Donny, you're out of your element.
It's better to be Triple H that it is to be John Cena.
Triple H actually has the support and respect of those who possess both a Y-Chromosome and pubic hair.
by *Asterisk* on Dec 6, 2011 4:54 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
I respect...
John Cena.
Dude is a workhorse and consistently has good matches.
His character is just bland, is all.
by Sergio Hernandez on Dec 6, 2011 5:10 PM EST up reply actions
Cena's one of the most inconsistent guys in the company.
For every masterpiece he puts forth in the ring, i.e. his Punk, Michaels, and Umaga matches, he puts on a WMOTY contender, i.e. his matches with Miz, Big Show, and R-Truth.
Cena doesn’t get the same respect that guys like Bret Hart, Triple H, and Undertaker get becasue even though he has had fantastic matches, is strong as an ox, and remarkably well conditioned, Cena’s clumsy. Cena has always been clumsy and always will be clumsy. Half the time he can distract from his clumsiness with his excellent sense of timing, fantastic strength, great conditioning, and ability to make everyone in the crowd hate him, but the other half of the time he looks like a backyarder who just happens to have a decade of experience, and that doesn’t even touch how bad his selling and psychology can be on a bad or even average day.
when Asterisk comments
dont aswer, just say AMEN, he’ll never accept someone else has a point
LOL
by chaggo on Dec 6, 2011 8:57 PM EST up reply actions 3 recs
Another thought on Cena
We all make fun of the kids who cheer everything he does no matter what. But how is it any different if you’re in your teens/early 20s and just boo him no matter what.
Either way, it’s a mark reaction.
Writer (and a handsome one at that),
And the Valley Shook
by Billy Gomila on Dec 6, 2011 11:58 PM EST up reply actions 2 recs
Booing somebody because their matches are boring, their character is terrible, and their promos are embarassing is not a mark reaction, it means you legitimately hate the guy, don’t want to see them on television, and most importantly, aren’t paying for their matches and merch.
I paid for two WWE PPV’s this year, Wrestlemania, and MitB. If I wanted to see Cena’s matches, I would’ve bought every WWE PPV this year, seeing as how he main evented all of them, and I bought two because I hate Cena and think he’s boring as fuck.
Sure, on some level you could argue he’s a meta heel for encouraging people not to buy his shows, but anybody dumb enough to sacrifice entertainment, quality, and money to make an ironic statement has a completely ass-backwards mindset, and isn’t worth paying attention to anyway.
Booing somebody because their matches are boring, their character is terrible, and their promos are embarassing is not a mark reaction
If you do it constantly and incessantly and it is your automatic reaction to whatever the wrestler does, yes it is.
Writer (and a handsome one at that),
And the Valley Shook
by Billy Gomila on Dec 7, 2011 11:58 AM EST up reply actions
I don’t want to buy any of the PPV’s Cena’s on, and I haven’t bought any of the PPV’s Cena’s been on unless there was a really awesome match on the card he had nothing to do with (i.e. Wrestlemania 27 with UT/Triple H), or his opponent found a way to make the prospects of a Cena match interesting (i.e. MitB with Cena/Punk). In fact, those were the only PPV’s from WWE I bought this year, and I don’t intend to buy another until ‘Mania 28, hell, I haven’t even watched RAW since WM 27.
Cena is an anathema to WWE business and buyrates, it doesn’t matter what the reason is, if you’re actively keeping people from buying PPV’s, you shouldn’t be on top.
So basically, you react to Cena no matter what.
Funny how that works out.
Writer (and a handsome one at that),
And the Valley Shook
I dunno
I think the art of the promo is dead. It’s the springboard for any enjoyable program and the worked-shoot the “hip” talent has fallen in love with only dazzles when it’s the exception, not the rule.
Gimme a fired-up Honky Tonk Man over this shoot-from-the-hip crap any day.
It is not enough to succeed. Others must fail.
THIS
I miss the days of the promo. I remember when guys used to have their own custom backgrounds & did promos with Mean Gene.
Do you think how promos seem to be so scripted now that it stifles that talent? I have had sales jobs where they say just get the job done and I could be myself. I have also had sales jobs where they give me a 10 page script which I have to follow. It takes a long time until I get it down smooth enough to be natural. Just imagine having to remember a scripted promo with maybe 1 hour to prepare.
by Manolo Has Pizzazz on Dec 7, 2011 1:56 AM EST up reply actions
In defense of Punk, we don’t really know how much power he has to change the booking of a contract signing, and we also don’t know how much time he had to prep for that segment. Perhaps they re-wrote the shows multiple times and Punk didn’t really know what he would be doing and was just told to grab a mic and talk his usual material during that segment.
So before blaming Punk I think we should first blame WWE booking for even having a contract signing. Seriously, who has contract signings for thrown together matches that nobody cares about? Usually the contract signings are for matches that have been brewing for a while and have a big-time feel to them. But this title match was just thrown together on that very show in a sloppy manner and then they topped it off with a contract signing. Could Punk have done anything to really save that? Nobody really cares about the Miz or Del Rio right now. It definitely would have been nice if Punk didn’t spit out the same stuff he said during the last contract signing, but even if he said something fresh would it really have turned that segment into anything noteworthy? The story behind this title match is non-existent and so nobody really cares about it.
This.
Maybe Freddie Prinze Junior wrote this one.
The problem is with creative. Maybe they have limited options because they are PG, but they write shit like they don’t want to make a lot of money. They are content with business as usual.
Seriously, who has contract signings for thrown together matches that nobody cares about?
John Laurinaitis does, that’s who. Do you dare challenge that man’s wisdom? He even had a nice little photo opportunity all set up. He is pure class.
by Manolo Has Pizzazz on Dec 7, 2011 1:59 AM EST up reply actions
Punk himself is regurgitating material from just two months ago.
Yet the same of you who say this, have orgasms when Rock regurgitates material from over a decade ago.
~Texas Massacre '09~
Follow me @The_Heat_
Friend me TheHeat
Google+ me TheHeat
He's not doing it under the premise that he's fighting agianst it, though.
That’s the key difference.
Forget it Donny, you're out of your element.
Here's what would a contract siging interesting, and give punk his "moment"...
If ol Punky pants walked out tho the contract siging and was all like “This is boring and is point, and I see no good reason to participate in this tomfoolery.” He then walks backstage, much to the chagrin of his peers and fans alike. “Well then we’ll go on without you,” they’ll say. But then from the bowels of the arena Punk drives in with a GODDAMN FORKLIFT! Tips over the ring, wrestlers and all and says, “I guess that’s one way to flip the table!” Climb out of the forklift grab a bunch of random objects from under the ring. And start pelting the other guys with them until they are forced to flee into the crowd. That way everyone gets over. The bad guys don’t look weak cause they were being assaulted by foreign objects and now have more of a reason to hate Punk, Punk looks cool as shit, and it’s kid friendly.
I had a similar idea
but no forklift needed. They could’ve just had Miz and Del Rio sign contracts before Punk came out, as well as wishing JoMo the best on his future endeavors. Then Punk can come out and before anyone is able to say a word, Punk flips over the table and starts beating on Del Rio and Miz. Than the back and forth brawl can continue with Punk ultimately coming out on top. There really was no need for Punk to cut a promo anyway, this would’ve just made him look like badass they want us to believe he is.
Does anyone notice HHH’s man love for the contract signings? HHH was in charge last night.. he ok’d that piece of crap show with 1 clean finish (diva’s match). I think HHH is ok w/ burying everyone.. either that or he’s been given waaaaaaay too much credit for being a smart man in the business. Maybe he’s not that smart.. maybe he’s gotten credit for other people’s work? If I was a paying customer to that show I would have demanded my money back. Can you imagine being a youngster & getting older talking about seeing a live show… and this is the one you get.. remember when Wade Barrett came down & Randy Orton ran after him to give Miz a count out? This show is hugely forgettable.. the Muppets episode was so much better. But I guess Punk looked strong.. he over came 3 people to stand tall in the end.
Probably calling Punk stale of all things is even funnier to me, since he’s the most fresh aspect of anything going on with this dead company. I mean the idea that Johnny Ace is given so much screen time and we had yet another useless contract signing to close out the show shows just how stale and simply lost the company is. Punk is just calling it like he sees it and as much as i’d like to see change I also know he doesn’t have the stroke or he wouldn’t be walking around with that gold toy belt in the first place. In the end as long as Vince and company are running the show the company will continue to put on forgettable to downright horrible shows, hell if it wasn’t for Punk i’d be done with them for good.
"@bigfootsilva, I want to tell you a joke so funny it will make your head grow. It goes like this..Oh wait, I see you have already heard it." -Chael Sonnen
Why is everybody so down on the contract signing concept?
Yes, I know it will end in a skirmish, but I don’t care. Just because point A and point C are predictable, that doesn’t mean point B is predictable. I enjoy promos so I always like to hear what is said before the fight breaks out.
As far as Punk goes, I have had enough of him. His current character blows. It’s like everything he says is contradictory to what he claims to stand for. Hypocrites really turn me off.
You can say John Laurinaitis has no charisma, but I don’t think he can be called uncreative. I have liked pretty much every decision Laurinaitis has made. His social experiment was unique with Cena and Ryder.
Looking back on HHH burying Punk in their contract signing seems to be prophetic. HHH pretty much laid the groundwork for what the current Punk character has now become.
by Manolo Has Pizzazz on Dec 7, 2011 1:46 AM EST reply actions



















