Cageside Fave Five: The best gimmick matches in pro wrestling
After last Sunday's WWE TLC pay-per-view (PPV), I got to thinking about how backwards it was for WWE to center entire events around gimmick matches. They do the same thing with the Hell in a Cell show and down in Florida TNA is just as guilty every year when they put on Lockdown.
Gimmick matches were supposed to be part of the natural evolution of a feud. Trying to get the belt off a cowardly rulebreaker whose friends keep running in and interfering? It's time for a cage match. Have a bitter feud that is tearing the promotion apart? A Loser Leaves Town match would certainly seem fitting.
But now guys step inside a Hell in a Cell simply because they happen to be feuding when that PPV comes up. No evolution, no natural progression, nothing.
So to celebrate -- or mourn, maybe -- the gimmick match, here's my top five in pro wrestling.
OH! But before we begin, I was totally remiss not to include this in my Fave Five entrance themes list.
Even my special lady admitted this song was the jam.
5. Tables match
If I told a non-fan the concept of a tables match, for sure they'd be interested. "How do you win?" "You can to put your opponent through a wooden table."
Hot damn, I'm excited just thinking about.
4. Cage match
I should preface this pertains to "escape only" cage matches. Like Tables and Ladder matches, I love matches where there can only be one way to win. In this cage, you have to climb a 10 foot or so high chain-link fence before your opponent can get his hands on you.
I also love the element that no one can interfere, making it the perfect match for that rulebreaker who always finds a way to win through nefarious means.
3. Ladder match
Why ladder and not TLC? Well, when you break it down, a TLC match is still just a ladder match. You can't win by doing anything with the tables and chairs, you still have to climb up and snatch the title that is hanging above the ring.
The inclusion of a ladder into match pretty much guarantees that you'll see something insane. All the way from WrestleMania X to a more recent classic like the one at No Mercy 2008 -- both involving Shawn Michaels -- the ladder match has become a fantastic way to end a title feud.
It's also a cool way to determine a number one contender like Ring of Honor (ROH) did at Death Before Dishonor or TNA does with its Ultimate X matches.
Just make sure something valuable is suspended above the ring, not something nonsensical like say, a sledgehammer. Ahem.
2. I Quit match
Hands down, the best blowoff match -- the ending of a feud -- has got to be Magnum TA and Tully Blanchard at Starrcade 1985. Not only was it an I Quit match but it was also inside of a steel cage! The ending came when the fan favorite was jamming a wooden shard into Blanchard's forehead, forcing the Horseman to quit.
Watch this match and listen to how unbelievably hot the audience is. It's nuts. An I Quit match is probably the best way to end a rivalry that has so much hatred behind it. Forcing your foe to actually quit, actually say it is sold as the most satisfying experience for a wrestling long embroiled in a seemingly neverending feud.
1. Iron Man match
And this applies only to the 60 minute variety, not these half hour and even 15 minute abominations (although the FCW 15 Minute title is pretty cool).
For the most part, companies will only agree to an hour-long match if they know the two wrestlers can sustain excitement for that long. For me, an hour long wrestling match between two guys that can work is just about as good as it gets in wrestling.
There you have it, folks. What do you think? And happy holidays!
17 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
30 minute IM's are still pretty good
Rude-Steamboat from Bash at the Beach ’92 is still a favorite.
Writer (and a handsome one at that),
And the Valley Shook
Bring back the big blue cage
I like the blue cage WWE used to use over the fence cage they currently use. I also agree escape only is the way to go.
by Manolo Has Pizzazz on Dec 24, 2011 3:02 PM EST reply actions
So much this
I wouldn’t mind if the chain link fence were still fought under escape, pin, or submission rules. The blue cage should be brought back as escape only.
The 984 Has Spoken!
One thing that bugs me about cage matches...
…Is that these days, they’re pretty much all “escape-only”. I thought the point of the cage was two-fold: to a) keep out interference (which fails on a regular basis) and b) keep two wrestlers locked in to settle their score definitively.
On that last point, how can two wrestlers definitively settle their score when one of them runs the frick away? Yes, I realize the idea there is to beat the other guy down so much that they can’t stop you from exiting the cage, but to me, that’s never as satisfying as seeing someone trapped like a rat, unable to escape someone who hates them direly and is entirely willing to beat them into total submission. Besides, it opens the door (no pun intended) for mind-screwy finishes like JBL’s win by being slammed through and crawling under the ring, or as seen here in the last week, RVD getting thrown through the cage and winning. Ugh.
I would much prefer to see more cage matches with the escape clause removed. Pin, submission, or knockout. Of course, I’d also like to see more cage matches where the idea of “the cage prevents interference” wasn’t subverted, but wishful thinking there.
Time to spread a little chaos...
I guess the HiaC match has taken over as the No Escape Clause cage match
I can understand your point though.
The 984 Has Spoken!
True...
But its separation from the ring itself on the floor also adds weapons into the mix which (barring that interference that’s not supposed to happen but sometimes does anyway) don’t come into play in a regular cage match. So you’d still have the tiers of progression.
Also, HiACs have still gone outside (and even on top of) the Cell (though not that I can remember in the PG-era). So it still loses that “locked in a cage with someone who wants to practically kill me” feeling to a small degree (probably one of the good things to come out of the PG era as far as the Cell goes, actually).
Time to spread a little chaos...
Dozens of gimmick matches
And 90% are either steel cage or no DQ/weapons-related. So I guess my faves are:
1-Steel cage
2-No DQ/weapons-related.
Iron man matches (of at least an hour, less is a joke) are cool, but have built-in boring spots. Understandable, but still…
Last man standing/I Quit matches are basically the same thing, and are just weapons matches with specific endings.
Gillberg...Gillberg...Gillberg...
I never got the...
Appeal of a Last Man Standing match. It’s like, instead of a three count pinfall, you have to get a 13 count one.
by Sergio Hernandez on Dec 24, 2011 3:50 PM EST up reply actions
I hate them with a passion
because the fucking referees always take like 3 seconds between each count. It’s horrible.
Forget it Donny, you're out of your element.
Hell in the Cell and Elimination Chamber would definitely make my list.
The WWE has watered down those matches……for good reason. Ladder match and I Quit matches would be number one and two with Hell in the Cell and Elimination Chamber matches following. I guess I would put steel cage match last.
Shawn Michaels vs Bret Hart Iron Man Match
Might be my favorite match of all time.
Bloody Elbow Grappling Editor.
Follow me on Twitter @KJGould
Like me on Facebook
The Iron Man between HHH and The Rock
From Judgement Day whatever year it was. . .I want to say 2000. . .was pretty awesome, too.
The thing that puts it over the Michaels/Hart match for me, personally, is that it’s really tough to believe that nobody would get pinned at all in that one. Pretty sure the Rock/HHH match finished something like 6-5 or something.
SBNation Minnesota - For the greatest sports fans in the world.
The Daily Norseman - The greatest Vikings' site on the Internet!
"Don't do anything by half. If you love someone, love them with all your soul. When you go to work, work your ass off. When you hate someone, hate them until it hurts." - Henry Rollins
Follow @DailyNorsemanSB
Follow @SBNMinnesota
by Christopher Gates on Dec 25, 2011 12:10 PM EST up reply actions
How About
A Fave Five list of matches? Here’s mine:
1. Undertaker vs Shawn Michaels, WrestleMania 25
2. Undertaker vs The Rock vs Kurt Angle, Vengeance 2002
3. Triple H vs Chris Benoit vs Shawn Michaels, WrestleMania XX
4. Kurt Angle vs Brock Lesnar (60 Minute IronMan match), SmackDown! 2003
5. Shawn Michaels vs Kurt Angle, WrestleMania 21
by WatchTheThrone89 on Dec 25, 2011 9:32 AM EST via mobile reply actions
No love for Last Man Standing
and Submission matches. Those are always fun
Players who should be in the Hall of Fame: Pat TIllman, Dwight White, Donnie Shell, L.C. Greenwood, Ray Guy, Steve Tasker, Jack Butler, Greg Lloyd, Andy Russell, Cris Carter, Kevin Greene, Curtis Martin, Willie Roaf, Andre Reed and Jerry Kramer
"Back in my day we killed five hookers and thought nothing of it" Craig James



















