Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Knicks Beat Lakers With Familiar Strategy

Irv Muchnick suspects that Lance Cade may have suffered from Chronic Traumatic Encephelopathy

Was Lance Cade another sufferer of Chronic Traumatic Encephelopathy at the time of his death?  (Wikimedia Commons)

Dave Meltzer's obituary of Lance Cade in the latest Wrestling Observer Newsletter has led Irv Muchnick to suggest that Lance Cade may have suffered from Chronic Traumatic Encephelopathy after being scripted to take a beating with a chair as punishment for a breach of backstage WWE etiquette:

But as Meltzer’s story shows, the circumstantial evidence shows that Cade (real name Lance McNaught), addict or not, was certainly a prima facie candidate for the brain trauma disease now being called Chronic Traumatic Encephelopathy.

The Meltzer piece can be viewed (subscribers only) at http://www.f4wonline.com/content/view/17184/. It tells of how Cade, who had been trained and pushed by WWE great Shawn Michaels, "was beaten down with one brutal chair shot after another and … left for dead, in what looked like and it turns out was punishment," in a "no disqualification match" with Michaells on the October 6, 2008, edition of Raw.

The "punishment" was for having violated rookie etiquette in not having shown enough gratitude to Michaels, who had gifted Cade with a "clean pinfall" win over him in a prior match.

Not so incidentally, this took place nearly a year after Vince McMahon told CNN, in a fall 2007 documentary, that WWE was banning chair shots to the head. In fact, cranial chair shots continued all the way to January 2010 – by which time Linda’s Senate campaign was well under way.

In response, I gave further details about the beating and raised another angle worth exploring:  

I wrote about this incident over four months ago at Cageside Seats in a post entitled "Speaking of WWE’s shady callous nature, Lance Cade has been fired after successfully completing rehab":

http://www.cagesideseats.com/2010/4/8/1412006/speaking-of-wwes-shady-callous

Within that post is a link to a YouTube video of the match where Shawn quickly destroyed Cade with a chair. It should be noted that only one of the chair shots was to the head, which I suppose was progress compared to the similar punishment angle Chris Kanyon had to endure over five years earlier where he was scripted to take multiple chair shots to the head. The concussion angle to this incident obviously still applies nonetheless. But there’s another angle worth exploring. Namely, scripting someone to take a large number of unnecessary, painful chair shots all over his body as punishment may have contributed to Cade shortly thereafter having a pain pill induced seizure on a plane.

On a side note, I’m bit peeved at the notion pushed by some in the wrestling media that WWE did everything they could to help Cade, which ignores WWE booking him in that punishment angle, WWE firing him instead of sending him straight to rehab after the incident where he had a drug induced seizure on a plane, and firing him again as soon as he successfully completed rehab in his second stint in the company. Clearly Cade needed rehab in October 2008, but by all accounts he wasn’t offered it then and had to wait over a year to get it. Personally that doesn’t strike me as WWE doing everything they could to help him, as quickly as they could.

Irv also later raised a valid side question for that devout Christian, Shawn Michaels:

I wonder where Chrisitianity teaches people that the scene described above squares with the principles of Jesus.

Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

This is all speculation that WWE SCRIPTS chair shots as locker room punishment. With Lance Cade those chair shots happened to be delivered by the man who trained him, put him over clean and helped him get a spot in WWE in the first place. So two respected journalists want to sell me on the story that HBK was so angry that Cade didn’t shake his hand that HBK went into the booking meetings and had Vince or Stephanie or whomever, book chair shots so HBK could teach Cade, his former student and at the time the only one of his students to make it to WWE, a lesson in wrestling manners. Not buying that at all.

As far as laying any blame on WWE for Cade, I’m sorry but I can’t. Firstly, when Cade was caught in a drug induced seizure on a plane he was fired but they still sent him to rehab. Next he called his WWE contacts and said he was clean and wanted another chance and he got it. Cade fell off the wagon again and was sent to rehab and then fired AFTER rehab for basically lying about being clean. Then, regardless of how long he had to wait, Cade was put in rehab a THIRD time by WWE, this time, even Meltzer admitted on his radio show on 8-18-10, WWE had people seeking him out to check on his status and Cade made himself unreachable.

Irv Mushnick has argued in the Benoit case that repeated blows to the head over a long period of time would lead to CTE. Now they want to say this one chair shot did it to Lance Cade?

Look I hate hearing about wrestlers dying young and WWE can and should do more for their performers but of all the wrestlers that have died over the years WWE did more for Lance Cade than any of them. Its a shame he died but its a bigger shame that he didn’t use one of those chances to save his life. At some point it has to be about what these guys want to do with their lives and not how many safe guards WWE has to put in place to not be perceived as shady callous and uncaring employers.

It really pisses me off because I ask myself would Chris Candido, a wrestler I loved to watch and was truly great, be alive today had he had as many free chances to get clean as Lance Cade did? What about Brian Pillman who had a wife and kids? If I could pull them out of their graves and tell them what WWE did for Cade what would they say about his death?

This is a shitty business when any salacious backstage theory of events gets treated like the gospel truth. I just can’t believe that the HBK I watched 2002-2010 would be that cold to want to hurt his own student for a handshake. If it is true then why in the hell are we watching and buying this shit? Why in the world would WWE bring this guy back after 3 rehabs and let him keep his job? Isn’t that enabling? Aren’t you saying "hey guys its all good rehab as many times as you need you’ll still have a spot here with us!

Freedom is a road seldom traveled by the multitudes...

by Major on Aug 19, 2010 6:36 PM EDT reply actions   1 recs

Well put, M.

It really pisses me off because I ask myself would Chris Candido, a wrestler I loved to watch and was truly great, be alive today had he had as many free chances to get clean as Lance Cade did? What about Brian Pillman who had a wife and kids? If I could pull them out of their graves and tell them what WWE did for Cade what would they say about his death?

The sad thing is that it’s all speculation. We’ll never know for sure about the truth behind the scenes. It’s funny how the ‘journalists’ who make their money off of wrestling like to expose its dirty laundry the most.

by FighterHayabusa on Aug 19, 2010 7:18 PM EDT up reply actions  

If you read my original post on the matter, I’m not suggesting that Shawn went to Vince and asked him to beat up Cade with a chair. Vince was upset with him before Shawn was, so I believe Vince came up with the chair beating angle to bury Cade and Shawn went through with it, at a time when chair shots to the head were supposedly banned. Given the timing it’s hard to believe that there was no malice involved in booking the angle, but it’s irrelevant whether the angle was locker room punishment or not. What’s important is that it happened and they recklessly endangered the health of one of their performers for no good reason.

To the best of my knowledge, you’re mistaken about the number of times WWE paid for Cade’s rehab. Dave Meltzer only mentioned WWE paying for him to go to rehab in February of this year. If he was sent to rehab three times by WWE, then that would obviously put a different perspective on matters, but that doesn’t seem to be the case.

Of course this one chair shot by itself wouldn’t have led to CTE, but it could have led to an undiagnosed concussion, which could lead to more brain trauma by continuing to work through the injury. Moreover, by the very nature of his profession he would have suffered repeated blows to the head over a long period of time.

by Keith Harris on Aug 20, 2010 7:28 AM EDT up reply actions  

Oh, and Brian Pillman was asked to go to rehab by WWE, but he turned it down.

by Keith Harris on Aug 20, 2010 7:31 AM EDT up reply actions  

You believe that Vince McMahon disliked him so much that he wanted to bury him with a chair shot angle instead of just pining Cade and making him a jobber and Shawn Michaels just goes with it because Cade didn’t shake his hand. Since this is fact in your mind and in Meltzers’ and Irv Mushnick then you need to get the fuck off this blog and call the police or Cade’s lawyers and family because that is aggravated assault. You are stating as FACT that Vince set out to hurt this man on purpose and HBK was the instrument to inflict a malicious act of violence upon a human being that HBK trained, cared for and helped his career to the point that he jobbed for Cade when he didn’t have to. So in a week all that history HBK has with Cade goes in the trash because Vince wants to kill him?

An excerpt on Cade from Figure Four;


 Cade was fired from WWE on October 14, 2008 after passing out on an airplane due to taking too many somas. It would have only been his first WWE Wellness policy violation, but the company was so concerned that he was immediately fired. He was very upset about it initially, but later admitted that the company did the right thing. He was re-signed in September of 2009 but was still having problems and eventually asked the company if they’d pay for him to go to rehab. They did and he spent a good deal of time there, getting high marks for how hard he worked to get clean. For whatever reason, upon completing rehab the company dropped a storyline they had planned for him and released him again. Despite this turn of events, someone who spoke with him as recently as a few months back said he appeared to be clean and sober, and that it seemed like his head was in the right place.

Last week he’d been looking bad and reported problems breathing, and on Tuesday night passed out and was rushed to the hospital. They revived him, but he woke up and was very upset about being hospitalized and demanded to be released. He stormed out of the house after returning home. He went to his father’s work and his father remembered him not looking good at all. He was very concerned and called Lance’s wife Tanya to tell her about it. She had not seen him since he stormed out of the house. Cade asked to stay at his father’s house and was found dead on Thursday evening with word getting out the next day, the day he was scheduled to leave for a two week tour of All Japan. He leaves behind two daughters and a stepson.

Michaels, who Cade idolized and who Tanya told WWE officials to please be sure to contact on Friday morning with the news, tweeted: “Aft my morning tweet I got the call about Lance. No words will b good enuff. 1 of my boys is gone. My prayers & thoughts have already been given 2 his family & will continue. Goodbye Lance I Love You. I ask that all of u would lift his family up in prayer.”

So you are correct it was two times that WWE paid for Cade to enter rehab. One interesting note is Cades’ Wife Tanya wanted WWE officials to get to HBK with news. It would seem to me that had Cade been punished and knew HBK did it to him that he would have hated him for it and his wife would’ve known that.

Brian Pillman turned down rehab, Cade didn’t. Pillman lived in a era where saying you had a problem was saying you had a weakness. In this day and age, a guy going to rehab is no issue at all in wrestling and WWE should be commended for breaking that stigma. Scott Hall is back in WWE sponsored rehab and I hope it works out for him but it took him years to admit his problem because like Pillman, Hall is “old school.” Jeff Hardy, Kurt Angle, Carlito, Umaga all turned down rehab too. The point here is if Pillman lived in this era he would’ve been more apt to take the treatment and not try to save face.

Freedom is a road seldom traveled by the multitudes...

by Major on Aug 20, 2010 9:28 AM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"Behind you there may be one, or there may be many, waiting to stick a knife in your back. But you don't have to worry about me ... I'll shoot you right between the eyes." -- Kevin Nash

Managers

Solidsnake_small Geno Mrosko

Editors

Small Keith Harris

Garth-knight_small Jesse Holland

File1684_small Sergio Hernandez