Cageside Seats: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Along The Olentangy for Ohio State Fans!

Responding to a Moderate Version of the "Bloodsport" Article

3487402624_100482d48e_medium

OregonLive.com has a story up by John Canzano about his experience at UFC 102.  He enjoyed the event but felt that it was... you guessed it: too violent and dangerous.  He spends the majority of the article painting a picture of a sport where the competitors get little more than the chance at physical injury from it.  He spends no time discussing the show of skill featured in all of the fights.  While I was stunned at the reversals pulled off by Nogueira, as well as Couture's ability to nullify the former's guard game, John Canzano was apparently focusing on something else. He admits that the sport appears more violent than it looks, and other sports are violent as well, but then he says:

I'd say that the state athletic commission needs to stop worrying about entertainment dollars and start putting the safety of the fighter first. And that the UFC referees need to be quicker to stop fights. And that the gloves of the fighters should have more padding.

First, I guess I should thank John Canzano for not using overly ridiculous descriptions of the fighters and fights.  Unfortunately, if he is really concerned about athletes and feels that it is his duty to improve their lives by writing about it, he is failing at his job.  In the name of safety for all athletes, I encourage Canzano to write a piece about the dangers of cheerleading, which a recent study found to be the most dangerous sport in the world. 

How about basketball, baseball, or football?  Hell, don't just write about them (I know, he already does), but target the main organizations for each and encourage them to use more padding, add more rules, and essentially change the sports.  If you're concerned about injuries, these sports should be looked at before MMA, according to the facts that are out there. 

Star-divide

According to a 2006 study, trampolines were pretty dangerous as well, and when was the last time someone wrote an anti-trampoline piece?  It probably wouldn't sell.  Considering the popularity of all the sports and activities on that 2006 list (as well as the lack of popularity and thus lack of information on MMA injuries) it seems that if you are trying to save lives and prevent injuries, these sports would be your best bet.

But football is as American as a bald eagle flying in front of a flag (wait a second...), and chances are football fans and the NFL wouldn't care what anybody, even if it was the best doctor in the world, had to say about their sport.  Football players know what they're signing up for.  They might be signing up for an early death, a life plagued with injuries, as well as a big payday.  The difference between football and MMA is, well, for one, someone dying while playing football no longer causes much of a stir.  It happens, and compared to the one death in a MMA, it happens at an exponentially higher rate.  According to an article from the Cincinnati Enquirer:

From 1976-2001, 162 players died from injuries; During 1966-75, 213 players died.

To date, there has been one death as a result of a sanctioned MMA fight. Still, MMA will always be a more logical target for attack due to the nature of the sport.  Football has fancy playbooks that detract from the violence, while MMA is about a "simple" fight. The fact that you can walk into a bar the night of a UFC PPV and hear at least one person claim they could beat a UFC fighter speaks volumes about the public's misunderstanding of the skill associated with the sport.  The same person wouldn't likely say the same thing about a boxing match, because the sport is more established and the majority of the public understands the skill involved.  Coincedentally, the majority of the public isn't shouting for boxing to be banned, even though several fighters die every year as a direct result of it.

Another frightening aspect of Canzano's article is his failure to distinguish the cause of injuries and possible deaths.  He says:

Because it turns out most of those in the crowd were rooting for big knockouts and devastating kicks. And as hard as I tried to pull for one fighter or another to win, I always found myself secretly pulling for the fight to be settled by a decision and for everyone to walk away with his marbles intact.

As someone with even a small amount of knowledge about MMA or combat sports in general would know, a drawn out war that goes to a decision is likely to include a much higher number of punches landed to the head.  A fight that ends with a fighter choked unconscious could end with none, although, to the average observer, it appears much more brutal since they don't know what they're looking at.  If you think that being unconscious is closely related to dying or being seriously injured, I discourage you from going to any Brazilian jiu-jitsu school, or even hanging around people who drink to intoxication.  As an MMAWeekly report states:

Most deaths in boxing are caused by acute subdural hematoma, which is basically bleeding on the brain caused by sudden head trauma. Any activity that involves blows to the head, MMA included, presents this risk.

In short, the longer an MMA fight stays on the feet, the more danger there is for a boxing-style death.

I don't expect the Canzano's of the world (and he was much more respectful of the sport than many who have written on this topic before him) to go away anytime soon, but it doesn't make their shockingly unshocking articles any less tiring.  We live in a society that often decides what is right and wrong based on how long something has existed or how much money can be made off of it, rather than what is factually and logically correct.  Until MMA proves to be a reliable source of income for mainstream journalists and politicians, I expect these types of articles to be churned out regularly.  Like nearly all sports, MMA is dangerous and comes with its own unique set of risks.  As an informed viewer, or just someone who takes a small amount of time to do some searching knows, it is far from the most dangerous sport.  If journalists are going to take the danger route while writing a piece about MMA, I suggest they start prefacing every article about an NFL, NHL, or MLB game with similar theatrics.

0 recs  |  Comment 4 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Surely you realize that using raw numbers to compare football and MMA is ludicrous. Millions of people play football on all levels. Very few people, comparatively, fight in MMA.

The guy is right: someone will die in the Octagon someday. To deny that is fooling yourself about what you are watching.

by JonathanSnowden on Aug 31, 2009 12:41 PM EDT reply actions  

I don’t think it is ludicrous if the intent is to prevent as many deaths or injuries as possible. You go for the biggest pool of people if you’re honestly looking to decrease injuries.

Yes, someone will absolutely die in the UFC at some point. I’m sure someone will die while sitting in the office chair rather soon as well. Someone will die on a football field soon as well. The point is that the UFC is a small fish in the big pond of violence in sports. Writing about violence in the UFC is easy and pointless. Writing about violence in the sports that the majority of Americans love and will defend at all costs would take courage.

by bag flack on Aug 31, 2009 1:05 PM EDT reply actions  

But those overall numbers reflect the vast participation, not the inherent dangers. If you are pretending MMA is a safe sport, I really don’t know what to say.

by Ty Lannister on Aug 31, 2009 3:45 PM EDT up reply actions  

It isn’t a safe sport, but neither is football, hockey, rugby, soccer, boxing, wrestling, etc. The point is that MMA is an easy target because its dangers are much closer to the surface than some of those other sports. It’s easier to write an article about someone getting choked out than it is to write about the effect of a tackle. Both happen daily in sports, but if one (the tackle) is sensationalized, the general public is knowledgeable enough to see through it and recognize the simple and obvious fact that sports are dangerous and when you participate in them you accept the consequences of your chosen sport. Not true with MMA, which is a new sport without overwhelming support from the public. People still compare MMA fighters to animals who are forced to fight against their will. As long as sentiments like that exist, you are kidding yourself if you think people are considering this issue with a full deck.

by bag flack on Aug 31, 2009 4:11 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Cageside Seats provides daily coverage of mixed martial arts, pro wrestling, boxing, and everything in between. Looking for in-depth and provocative commentary on the fight industry? Look no further!
Start posting on Cageside Seats »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

SBNation.com Recent Stories

Seattle Seahawks, T.J. Houshmandzadeh pushes off Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Sabby Piscitelli, who tries to push Houshmandzadeh out of bounds during the first half of an NFL football game, Sunday, Dec. 20, 2009, in Seattle. At left is Ronde Barber. (AP Photo/John Froschauer)

Report: Seahawks Considering Trading T.J. Houshmandzadeh

PITTSBURGH - AUGUST 25:  Byron Leftwich #4 of the Pittsburgh Steelers warms up prior to the preseason game against the Carolina Panthers on September 2 2010 at Heinz Field in Pittsburgh Pennsylvania.  (Photo by Jared Wickerham/Getty Images)

Steelers Quarterback Byron Leftwich Leaves Game With Left Knee Injury

Photo link

In Progress: Miami Leads Florida A&M 42-0 In Third Quarter

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Violator__remastered_-_sacd__small Bix

Editors

Yhst-50863389838911_2094_21631803_small JonathanSnowden

Th_alkredblack_bigger_small SundownMotel

Small Cox813

Small Dave Walsh

Small kjh

Small DylanWaco

Small SLL

Authors

849514479_l_small jlamb

Walter_small Geno Mrosko

Kangaroo_small Matthew DiRienzo

Small Jeremiah Johnson.